Left Behind LLC

Left Behind LLC is a locally owned thrift store located at 205 W Wisconsin Ave in Appleton, Wisconsin, specializing in secondhand furniture, clothing, home décor, and other gently used items. The business began as an online operation in 2021 and expanded to open its brick-and-mortar location in May 2023, offering both in-store shopping and online resale services to customers throughout the Fox Valley area and nationwide. Left Behind is centered on sustainability practices, focusing on recycling, repurposing, and reusing items that might otherwise end up in landfills. Owner Michael Day founded the company after discovering discarded items during his property management work, transforming these forgotten goods into affordable treasures for other shoppers. The business also offers free local pickup for gently used items from customers looking to declutter or downsize.