Maggie’s Closet

Maggie’s Closet is one of the largest consignment shops in southeastern Wisconsin, located at 127 E. Mill Street in Plymouth. Founded in 2013, the privately-owned business features two full floors of brand-name clothing for women, men, juniors, and plus sizes, along with jewelry, purses, accessories, furniture, and home décor. The store specializes in curated consignment items designed to offer high-end bargains in a boutique-style setting, with new inventory arriving daily. Beyond retail operations, Maggie’s Closet serves as a community gathering space emphasizing sustainability, connection, and style, attracting long-time consignors and customers who view the business as part of their family. The business has expanded to include a second location in Milwaukee’s Third Ward, opened in July 2025.