The Picky Picky Resale Shop

The Picky Picky Resale Shop, established in 2014, is a resale shop located at 301 W Main Street in Waukesha, Wisconsin that specializes in selling quality, clean vintage items including gaming systems, vinyl records, collectibles, comic books, and hard-to-find treasures. The shop buys, sells, trades, and consigns both new and used merchandise across a wide range of categories including antiques, arcade games, clothing, and household goods. Known for its customer-focused service, the business has grown significantly since its founding through customer loyalty and community engagement in downtown Waukesha.